Reviews For Who Talks of Victory
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: DanieXJ Anonymous [Report This]
Date: 25 Feb 2007 01:52 pm Title: Chapter 1

I thought that the characterizations were unique. I mean, yeah, is Sam Perfect, and Jack perfectly evil in Canon, no... but that's why FanFic exists, for the author to do whatever in the world he or she wants to...

Awesome story!! Thanks!!!

Author's Response: Thanks for the feedback, I hope you continue reading my stories. Sabine (aka romansilence)

Reviewer: gtraveller Anonymous [Report This]
Date: 28 Nov 2006 11:39 am Title: Chapter 1

In your Warning you mention O'Neill being 'too perfect to be true' - well you should also have warned us about your version of Sam - I have never seen anyone portrayed so wonderfully, impossibly perfect that it is just plain ridiculous! The way the other characters - except O'Neill of course! - react to her I wonder they don't approach her on bended knee! Good god, if you are going to write an AU make it plausible and the characters recognisable. Please!

Author's Response: gtraveller - sorry that I come back to you this late. I usually take more care in answering feedback. Yes, Sam might be a bit too perfect. It might have been a reaction to TPTB portraying Sam in season 9 (10 has not been aired in my part of the swamp) and reading a few of the articles in the anthology "Reading Stargate". I hope you don't give up on my writing as a whole, though I tend to give Sam a lot of credit, no matter what. Sorry to be biased, Sabine (aka romansilence)

You must login (register) to review.